PROS:

Affordable
Luxury Brands from Sephora
Great Packaging

CONS:

Less Indie Brands
Waitlist
Less Deals

PROS:

Recyclable Box
Affordable
Indie Products

CONS:

Less Luxury Products
Smaller Samples
Lacks Variety... Same Brands

Overall I believe the Sephora Play! Box is a much better box. Both boxes are 10 dollars but you get way better products from Sephora. Just because Sephora has so many connections to on-trend luxury brands that are really relevant now. Overall for me Sephora Wins.

As a side note, I will mention that all of the Chief officers at Sephora are male, the only female mentioned on Bloomberg is the VP of Retail&Education. I am slightly disappointed just due to the fact that you would think that a company that is targeted towards women would be run by women. Women are very underrepresented in management and this is just another example of this.